詞曲:宋冬野
她發現孤獨的人准備動身
於是就禱告著
黃昏
直到夜裡她轉頭聽見
悲傷的嗚咽
一個善良的女子
長發垂肩
她已跟隨黃昏
來臨
翠綠的衣裳在爐火中
化為灰燼
升起火焰一直燒到
黎明
一直到那女子
推開門離去
她自言自語
在離這很遠的地方
有一片海灘
孤獨的人他就在海上
撐著船帆
如果你看到他
回到海岸
就請你告訴他你的名字
我的名字
莉莉安
吉他/和聲:宋冬野
編曲/鋼琴:韋偉
弦樂:李琪弦樂團
作者:老竹
链接:https://www.zhihu.com/question/21621837/answer/94318786
来源:知乎
著作权归作者所有。商业转载请联系作者获得授权,非商业转载请注明出处。
宋冬野说,《莉莉安》是写他一个曾患精神分裂的朋友。这个朋友在自己内心幻想出一个男人,并与他相爱,后来男人走了,她很想他,于是又幻想出另外一个女人,并让这个女人帮她去寻找那个她爱的那个男人。
宋冬野接受音乐媒体采访的原话我打出来了,大家可以对照着看:
莉莉安是我一个朋友她精神出了问题
然后她住到了北京的一个精神病院
后来她出来之后她给我讲她生病的时候脑子里都在想些什么
她大概讲的就是她自己是女人A
她觉得她变成了女人A和男人A然后这两个人相爱了 还特别好
然后突然有一天发生了一点什么样的很刺激的事情
然后她就觉得那个男人A没有了 走了但是她又特别思念他
然后就特别郁闷
后来她感觉她又变成了女人A和女人B
她就让女人B帮她去找男人A说如果你找得到了你就告诉她我的名字就可以了
然后我就给她润色了一个海边的场景写了这个[据56网《音乐下午茶》20140911期]
有了这个背景,解读这首歌歌词表层意思,也就不难。
她发现孤独的人准备动身于是就祷告着黄昏
心爱的那个男人,注定不属于自己,他要去远方寻找孤独。莉莉安觉察出这一切,但无能为力。她只能祈祷,祈祷一个人的出现,来帮她挽回这一切。
这个人会是谁?
直到夜里她转头听见悲伤的呜咽一个善良的女子长发垂肩她已跟随黄昏来临
从黄昏祈祷到深夜,那个人终于出现。她是个看起来善良温顺的女子,正在默默饮泣。她长发垂肩,神情悲伤,伴随黄昏而来。
翠绿的衣裳在炉火中化为灰烬升起火焰一直烧到黎明一直到那女子推开门离去
女子把身上穿的一件翠绿衣裳,投入火炉,烧成灰烬,升起火焰,一直烧到黎明。最终,女子推门而去。
她自言自语在离这很远的地方有一片海滩孤独的人他就在海上撑着船帆
眼看女子即将离去,莉莉安开始喃喃自语。她说,离这里很远的某个地方,有一片海滩,她心中深爱着的那个男人,就在那片海上,撑着船帆,独自沉浸在自己的孤独之中。
如果你看到他回到海岸就请你告诉他你的名字我的名字莉莉安
莉莉安对绿衣女子说,你即将远行,请求你帮我寻找那个男人。如果他刚好从海上回到岸边,就请你麻烦告诉他你的名字,也就是我的名字——莉莉安。
# 几个解读,不一定对 #男人为什么离开?
《莉莉安》歌词很简洁,给男人只有一个修饰语——「孤独」。这个孤独的人,在一开头就交代了说他动身离开。后面再通过女主人公的「自言自语」,讲述了他的现状——在很远的一个沙滩,撑着船帆在海上流浪,可能偶尔上岸,也可能一直在海上漂泊。我觉得李志的《梵高先生》有几句,刚好可以用来解读这个男人:「谁的爱人走了……我们生来就是孤独,我们生来就是孤单。」是啊,人的孤独是与生俱来的,与其人群中孤独,不如海上飘零,与舟为伴。或许那个男人就是为了寻找孤独而离开莉莉安。绿衣女人是谁?
绿衣女人是莉莉安幻想出来的另一个她自己,所以最后会说「你的名字」也就是「我的名字」。莉莉安先是在心里构拟出一个孤独的他,并与他相爱,然后他又离开,远行去寻找属于自己的孤独。说明莉莉安的内心,对爱既渴望又抗拒。而当彻底失去时,又无法不去思念,可是她无法跨出那一步,她需要借助一个化身,去寻找那个孤独的人。这个化身,就是绿衣女子。翠绿衣裳有何象征?
绿衣是个十分古老的文学意象。《诗经·邶风·绿衣》,一首怀念已逝爱人的悼亡诗,绿衣承载着已经逝去的爱人的回忆和爱,「心之忧矣,曷维其已」,这份优思何时能停止,那就烧了吧,不去思念,一了百了。莉莉安眼看着绿衣女子将翠绿衣裳投入火炉,过往一切化为灰烬,火焰明亮如昼,似乎只有忘记过去,才能重新燃起新生活的火苗。可是真的管用吗?女子将离之际,莉莉安又开始倾诉心中郁结,看似自言自语,其实是苦苦嘱托。
# 作者自己的解读 #(来自宋冬野本人豆瓣)
动机:一个关于精神分裂的梦。 详细:我的朋友们最喜欢的一首歌,大概也是我的旋律感最强的一首,是这张专辑(《安河桥北》)里最早创作,也是第一个编曲完成的歌,如果把它送给尧十三老湿,那就再合适不过了。编曲配器我很喜欢,尤其喜爱间奏中弦乐和古筝的对话,有种左左右右应接不暇的感觉,Double Bass的效果很古典很轻盈,又不抢戏,律动直接走起来了,完整又舒服。这首歌同时用了一条完整的采样,虽然离真正的氛围音乐还有些差距,但至少我自己感觉很好。(完)
————————————————————————————————————
欢迎关注我的歌词解读公众号:【读歌记】(微信号:dugeji)
Lyrics & Composition: Song Dongye (宋冬野)
She saw a lonely soul getting ready to depart,
So she whispered a prayer to the dusk.
Until night fell, she turned and heard
A sorrowful sobbing—
A kind-hearted woman
With long hair draped over her shoulders—
She had arrived along with the twilight.
Her emerald dress turned to ash
In the fireplace’s flame,
The fire rising and burning
All the way until dawn.
Until that woman
Opened the door and left,
Muttering to herself:
Far away from here,
There’s a beach.
And the lonely one is out at sea,
Holding up a sail.
If you see him
Return to the shore,
Please tell him your name—
And mine:
Lilian.
Author: Lao Zhu
Source: Zhihu (https://www.zhihu.com/question/21621837/answer/94318786)
All rights reserved by the original author. For commercial use, please contact the author for authorization. For non-commercial use, please credit the source.
Song Dongye once said that Lilian was written about a friend of his who had suffered from schizophrenia. This friend imagined a man in her mind and fell in love with him. Later, the man disappeared, and she missed him deeply. So, she imagined another woman and sent this woman to search for the man she loved.
I’ve transcribed Song Dongye’s original words from a music media interview. You can compare them to the lyrics:
“Lilian is a friend of mine. She had mental issues and ended up in a psychiatric hospital in Beijing. After she was discharged, she told me what her mind was like during the illness.
She said she was Woman A.
She felt she had become Woman A and Man A.
And these two people fell in love—deeply in love.
Then, one day, something extremely intense happened,
and she felt the man was gone.He vanished.
But she missed him terribly,
and fell into deep depression.
Later, she felt she became Woman A and Woman B.
And she asked Woman B to help her find Man A.
She said, ‘If you find him, just tell him my name.’So I polished this into a seaside scene and wrote this song.”
— [Music Afternoon Tea, 2014-09-11, 56.com]With this background in mind, it becomes easier to interpret the surface meaning of the lyrics:
“She saw the lonely man getting ready to leave,So she prayed to the twilight.”
The man she loved was destined to not belong to her. He was going far away, chasing solitude. Lilian sensed this—but was powerless to stop it. All she could do was pray—pray for someone to appear who might help her win him back. But who would that person be?“Until night fell, she turned and heard
Sorrowful sobbing—
A kind-hearted woman
With long hair draped over her shoulders—
She had arrived along with the twilight.”From dusk until late at night, the person finally appeared. A woman, seemingly kind and gentle, weeping quietly. Her long hair draped over her shoulders, sadness written all over her face—she arrived with the nightfall.
“Her emerald dress
Turned to ash in the fireplace.
Flames rose and burned
All the way until dawn.
Until that woman
Opened the door and left—”The woman threw her emerald green dress into the fireplace, burning it to ash. The fire roared, burning all through the night until dawn. Finally, the woman opened the door and left.
“She muttered to herself:
Far away from here,
There’s a beach.
The lonely man
Is out at sea,
Holding up a sail—”As the woman was about to leave, Lilian began muttering to herself. She said, in a faraway place, there’s a beach. And the man she loved was out there, on the sea, sailing alone—immersed in his own solitude.
“If you see him
Return to the shore,
Please tell him your name—
My name—
Lilian.”Lilian said to the woman in green, “You’re about to go on a journey. Please help me look for that man. If you happen to see him return to shore—just tell him your name. That is, tell him my name—Lilian.”
Interpretations (subjective, not definitive)
Why did the man leave?
The lyrics of Lilian are minimal and offer only one word to describe the man: “lonely.” This loneliness is clear from the very first line—he’s leaving. Later, through the woman’s “muttering,” we learn he’s now drifting on the sea near a distant beach. He may occasionally come ashore, or he might be endlessly drifting. The lyrics evoke a quote from Li Zhi’s Mr. Van Gogh:
“Someone’s lover left…We are born lonely. We are born alone.”
Indeed, human loneliness is inborn. Better to drift at sea than feel alone in a crowd. Maybe the man left Lilian in search of that very solitude.Who is the woman in green?
She is another version of Lilian herself—a figure Lilian imagined. That’s why the song ends with “your name—my name.”
Lilian first created a lonely man in her mind and fell in love with him. Then he left, in search of solitude. This reflects her inner struggle: she longs for love, but also resists it. When she lost him completely, she couldn’t stop missing him. Yet she couldn’t take that step herself—so she created a second self to go and find him. That second self is the woman in green.
What does the green dress symbolize?
Green is an ancient literary motif. In The Book of Songs, the poem “Green Garment” is a mourning song for a deceased lover. The green dress carries the memory and love of someone lost:
“My heart is sorrowful—When will it ever end?”
The act of burning the green dress becomes a symbol: letting the past turn to ash, so a new life might spark from the fire. But does it really work? As the woman in green is about to leave, Lilian starts speaking again—not truly to herself, but as a desperate plea. Her heart is still not at peace.
The songwriter’s own interpretation (via Douban)
Inspiration: “A dream about schizophrenia.”
Details:“This is my friends’ favorite song, probably also the one with the strongest sense of melody. It was the first song I wrote and arranged for the album North of Anhe Bridge. If I were to give it to Yao Shisan Laoshi (a songwriter friend), it would be perfect. I really love the arrangement—especially the conversation between strings and guzheng in the interlude. There’s this rapid back-and-forth feeling, like left–right–left–right. The double bass has this classical, light texture that doesn’t steal the show, but brings the rhythm alive. The track used a full-length sample. Even though it’s still far from being true ambient music, it felt really good to me personally.”